Singled Out: Bay Simpson's Too Good To Be True

Muscle Shoals native now based in Nashville and The Voice contestant Bay Simpson just released his rockin' brand new single "Too Good To Be True" and to celebrate we asked him to tell us about the track. Here is the story:

"Too Good to Be True" came from a feeling I couldn't really shake. This realization that some of the most important moments in your life don't feel important while you're living them. It's only later, when they're gone, that they start to mean everything. For me, that was growing up in the early 2010s. I didn't love high school when I was in it. I was ready to get out, ready to move on. But looking back now, I miss it more than I ever thought I would. That's really where the song started, just trying to make sense of that feeling.

I grew up in Muscle Shoals, Alabama, around real music, real songwriting, and people who cared about what they were saying. So when I sat down to write this, I wasn't thinking about trends or trying to chase anything. I just wanted to tell the truth. I wrote it with Brian Maher and James LeBlanc, and it came together pretty naturally once we locked into the idea. The line "it was too good, too good to be true" felt like the kind of thing you don't realize until it's already behind you. It's simple, but it hits hard because it's honest.

Recording it, I wanted it to feel like a memory; something a little worn in, a little nostalgic, but still alive. Not overproduced, not perfect. Just something that feels like it could've been playing in the background of your life at some point. That's always been important to me. I don't want songs to just sound good-I want them to feel like something people have lived through.

At the end of the day, this song is about perspective. It's about looking back and wishing you had slowed down, paid more attention, held onto things a little tighter. If someone hears it and it makes them think about their own life, their own memories, whether that's high school, a relationship, or just a moment they didn't realize mattered at the time, then I feel like it did its job.

Hearing is believing. Now that you know the story behind the song, listen and watch for yourself below and learn more here (including his blood relation to the King Of Rock and Roll himself, Elvis Presley, and watch his recent battle round on The Voice)

News > Bay Simpson